Sarah Madsen
- B.A. (University of Victoria, 2024)
Topic
“Against the Will of the City”: Anti-Populist Conspiracy Theories and the Judiciary during the Popish Plot Crisis, 1678-81
Department of History
Date & location
- Friday, November 27, 2026
- 9:00 A.M.
- Clearihue Building, Room B007
Examining Committee
Supervisory Committee
- Dr. Andrea McKenzie, Department of History, University of Victoria (Supervisor)
Dr. Simon Devereaux, Department of History, UVic (Member)
External Examiner
- Dr. John Craig, Department of History, Simon Fraser University
Chair of Oral Examination
- Dr. Leslee Francis Pelton, Department of Curriculum and Instruction, UVic
Abstract
The 1678-81 Popish Plot—a putative conspiracy to kill Charles II, overthrow Parliament and the Anglican Church, and re-establish Catholicism in England—resulted not only in a political crisis over the succession of the king’s Catholic brother, but also in a power struggle over the courts, revealing deeper political divisions across the social hierarchy. Initially, the largely Tory judicial bench went along with the prosecution of the Plot; however, this changed in 1679 with the acquittal of Queen Catherine of Braganza’s Catholic physician, George Wakeman. Wakeman’s trial was generally viewed as the queen’s trial and the charges appeared to be an especially shocking kind of insubordination to the Tories. In the fallout of Wakeman’s trial, the House of Commons attempted to regulate the bench, who the Whigs cast as tyrannical and arbitrary. This culminated in the Commons’s attempt to impeach the lord chief justice of the King’s Bench William Scroggs. This episode was steeped in anxieties over Catholicism, nonconformity, and unregulated political power. It reveals larger Tory concerns about growing populism in the City of London which threatened the social order and was dangerously reminiscent of the political tensions which had preceded the English Civil Wars.